Insurance Coverage Denied for Nonexistent Building: A Look at the Impact on Commercial Property Insurance

Thang Truong
Thang Truong
Updated on:

In a recent ruling that has sent ripples through the business insurance sector, a federal appeals court upheld that an insurance policy cannot cover a building that was non-existent at the time the policy was issued. This decision, favoring a unit of Hanover Insurance Group, has significant implications for businesses and their commercial property insurance costs.

The Case in Focus

The case in question involved Sector Corp, a property management company based in Portland, Oregon, and PSC Custom LLC, a company operating in the tank trailer and tank truck industry from Saint Cloud, Minnesota. In 2013, Sector Corp agreed to lease premises on its property in Billings, Montana, to PSC Custom. The lease agreement required Sector to acquire fire and casualty insurance for the entire premises, including any improvements made on it.Sector purchased commercial general liability insurance policies from Hanover American Insurance Co., a Hanover Insurance Group unit, from 2013 through 2019. In 2014, PSC Custom erected a 6,100-square-foot structure on the property, which was destroyed by a fire and explosion in 2019, resulting in repair costs exceeding $400,000.

The Court’s Ruling

When PSC Custom and St. Johns, the company managing insurance policies on Sector’s behalf, submitted claims to Hanover for the loss of the structure, Hanover denied the claims. The insurer argued that the policy did not expressly list the center as covered property on the premises.The U.S. District Court in Billings, Montana, ruled in favor of the insurer, a decision later affirmed by a three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco. The court stated that the policy provides coverage for physical loss or damage to “covered property,” which is defined to include a building or structure described in the policy’s declarations. Since the structure did not exist when the policy was issued in 2013, it was not covered under the policy.

Impact on Commercial Property Insurance Costs

This ruling underscores the importance of businesses thoroughly understanding their commercial property insurance policies. It also highlights the potential for increased commercial property insurance costs for businesses in high-risk sectors, as they may need to regularly update their policies to include new structures or improvements.

Advice for Small Businesses

In light of this ruling, small businesses should pay close attention when seeking a new commercial property insurance policy or renewing their current one. It is crucial to ensure that all existing and planned structures are explicitly covered in the policy. Regular reviews and updates of the policy are also necessary to accommodate any changes or additions to the property. Consulting with a knowledgeable insurance agent or broker can provide valuable guidance in navigating these complexities. Learn more at the best commercial property insurance companies.

Closing Remarks

This case serves as a stark reminder of the intricacies of commercial property insurance. Businesses must remain vigilant in understanding their coverage and ensuring that their policies accurately reflect their property’s current state. By doing so, they can avoid unexpected costs and ensure they are adequately protected against potential losses.

Thang Truong

Thang Truong covers small business insurance and small business success at BravoPolicy. He is a licensed P&C insurance agent. Previously, he held product leadership positions at realtor.com, Capital One, NerdWallet, and Mulberry Technology. He holds a MBA degree from UC Berkeley - Haas School of Business.

More Stories

Walmart’s Innovative Solution to Truck Driver Shortage: Training Its Own Employees

In response to the truck driver shortage experienced last year, retail giant Walmart took a novel approach by offering its vast workforce of 1.6 million employees the opportunity to learn how to drive a big rig for the company. This initiative included attractive first-year salaries of up to $110,000 and a comprehensive 12-week training program. […]

California’s Legislative Move to Bridge Insurance Data Gaps for Zero-Emission Trucks

California is making strides in its commitment to environmental sustainability, with a new bill in the statehouse aimed at addressing insurance data gaps for heavy-duty trucks and truck fleets that utilize advanced fuels and related technologies. This move comes as part of the state’s broader initiative to transition to zero-emission vehicle truck standards. The Clean […]

Workers’ Compensation Insurance: A Beacon of Stability Amidst P/C Sector Volatility

In 2022, the underwriting results of workers’ compensation insurers outshone the rest of the U.S. property/casualty (P/C) commercial sector. This success is attributed to the long-term decrease in workplace accidents and a reduction in fraudulent claims, as reported by an industry segment report from A.M. Best. Favorable Loss Reserve Development The report highlights that the […]

Arizona Beverages’ Victory: A Landmark Case for Business Interruption Insurance

In a recent landmark case, Arizona Beverages USA LLC emerged victorious in a lawsuit against a Hanover Insurance Group unit. The dispute centered around coverage for business interruption caused by a computer breakdown. This case has set a precedent, providing clarity on what constitutes extra expenses incurred by insureds to avoid or reduce business interruption. […]

J&J’s $18.8M Case: A Reminder of Product Liability Insurance

In a recent legal case, Johnson & Johnson, a multinational corporation known for its consumer goods, was ordered to pay $18.8 million to a California man who claimed to have developed cancer due to exposure to the company’s baby powder. This case serves as a stark reminder of the potential financial implications businesses may face […]

OSHA’s New Initiative: Enhancing Safety in High-Risk Retail Establishments

The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) has recently announced a national emphasis program aimed at mitigating workplace hazards in warehouses, processing facilities, distribution centers, and other establishments classified as “high-risk retail.” This initiative is a response to the growing concerns over the safety of these workplaces, which have seen a surge in accidents parallel […]

The Changing Landscape of Opioid Use in Workers Compensation Cases

The issue of opioid use in workers compensation cases has been a topic of concern for many years. However, recent data suggests a shift in the trend, with a decrease in opioid prescriptions but an increase in prescriptions for managing opioid dependency. This article delves into these trends and discusses the importance of workers compensation […]

A Landmark Victory: Dentist’s Insurance Claim Sets Precedent for COVID-19 Business Loss Coverage

In an unprecedented legal victory, a Pennsylvania dentist has successfully claimed insurance for business losses incurred due to the COVID-19 pandemic. This landmark case, involving Dr. Timothy A. Ungarean, DMD, D/B/A Smile Savers Dentistry, PC, has set a significant precedent for similar cases in the future. The state Supreme Court’s decision to hear this case, […]

The Struggles and Triumphs of Childcare Providers: A Case Study of Rockin’ Round the Clock

Childcare providers play a crucial role in society, nurturing and educating children during their most formative years. However, the challenges they face are often overlooked. This article explores the struggles and triumphs of childcare providers, focusing on a specific case study: Rockin’ Round the Clock, a childcare center in Ohio. The Challenges of Childcare Providers […]