Pie Insurance Review 2022

Thang Truong
Thang Truong
Updated on:

Pie insurance is a small business insurance company, mostly focusing on workers compensation, although they have other types of business insurance as well. Pie is part of a digital revolution in the small business insurance field. Companies such as Pie seek to make the entire process of buying business insurance faster, easier and completely online. 

Pie launched in 2018, covering just four states (Illinois, Georgia, Tennessee and Arizona). Now, they’re available in 34 states just two years later, and they have plans to expand to the remaining states. 

Pros and Cons of Pie Insurance 

– Online quoting
– Good reviews on Trustpilot
– Helpful resources on the website
– Newcomer to the insurance industry
– Workers compensation is the only insurance they offer on their own
– Not in every state yet

If you are looking for the best cyber insurance for your company, be sure to shop around with a few companies or with a digital broker like CoverWallet, Simply Business, or commercialinsurance.net to compare several quotes to select the best one for you.

Products Offered by Pie Insurance

Pie focuses on workers compensation insurance for small businesses.  They are able to offer other types of business insurance by pairing with other insurance companies. 

  • Business owners
  • Commercial auto
  • Errors and omissions
  • General liability
  • Professional liability
  • Small group health insurance

Workers compensation: This is what Pie specializes in, and in fact, it’s the only insurance they provide without pairing up with another insurance company. Workers compensation insurance is required in many states, even if you only have one employee. Pie claims they can save you 30% over other companies. 

Workers compensation insurance provides medical, disability, survivor, burial and rehabilitation benefits to your employees. 

The following are industries that Pie can provide coverage for:

  • Auto shops
  • Barbershops and salons
  • Cleaning companies
  • Construction
  • Electrical
  • Extermination
  • HVAC
  • Landscaping
  • Manufacturing
  • Painting
  • Plumbing
  • Restaurants and bars
  • Retail
  • Trucking and delivery

>>MORE: Best 7 Workers’ Compensation Insurance Companies for Small Business

>>MORE: Finding Workers Comp Insurance for Independent Contractors

Business Owners: Business owners insurance (or BOP) combines commercial property insurance, commercial liability insurance and business interruption insurance into one policy. Pie insurance pairs with Progressive to provide this insurance for their customers. 

Commercial Auto: Anyone who drives a company car for business needs commercial auto insurance. This is also offered through Progressive.

Errors and Omissions: E&O insurance protects you against claims by clients who believe you made a mistake that lead to their financial harm. Pie offers this insurance through Hiscox. 

General liability: General liability protects you from third party injuries, property damage and reputational harm. Progressive offers general liability insurance to Pie customers.

Professional liability: This is the same as errors and omissions insurance, and also the same as malpractice insurance but it is on Pie’s website under both names. Whatever you call it, they offer this insurance through Progressive. 

Health insurance for small businesses:  Pie is able to offer small business health insurance through eHealth. 

Financial Strength Rating of Pie Insurance

Pie is backed by and their policies are underwritten by the Sirius Group, so they earn an A- for financial strength from A.M. Best. This is reassuring, since Pie is a new company and relatively unproven. This means that Pie has the financial resources they need to pay claims. 

>>MORE: Best Small Business Insurance Companies 2020

Customer Satisfaction Rating of Pie Insurance

Since Pie is too recent to appear on J.D. Power’s Small Commercial Insurance study, we’ll look to other sources. 

Pie has an average of 4.6 out of five stars, based on 212 reviews on Trustpilot.  Most of the reviews are positive (91%), with 4% giving them one star and the rest in between. The positive reviews praise how easy Pie’s application process is (as easy as Pie, actually), how fast customer service addresses their concerns, and they saved money. The one star reviews remark on customer service, price and processing. 

The BBB seems not to have heard of Pie, so the reviews on Trustpilot are the only indication we have of what Pie’s customer service is like. 

>>MORE: Next Insurance Review; Thimble Insurance Review; Vouch Insurance Review

Consumer Complaints Rating of Pie Insurance

Pie is not listed on the NAIC’s website. This is to be expected, since they are a very young company. 

>>MORE: The 4 Best Business Owner Policy (BOP Insurance) Companies

Digital Experience Rating of Pie Insurance

You can get a quote on workers compensation insurance online, but you’ll need something called class codes. In order to provide you with a quote, they need to know what your employees do and what risks they might be exposed to. Someone who works in construction is exposed to more risk than someone who works in a nail salon. Riskier jobs pay higher premiums. 

Why can’t they just ask you what your employees do? Actually, workers compensation is regulated by the National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI) and some states have their own codes, so it varies, but they were created to provide some consistency across industries. 

You’ll also need to provide your annual payroll, which includes wages, salaries, bonuses and overtime. Location and claims history are also considered. Once you have all this information, Pie claims they can give you a quote in less than three minutes and save you about 30%.

If you need another type of business insurance, Pie will redirect you to either Progressive or to Hiscox. Progressive and Hiscox do offer online quoting as well. 

>>MORE: How Much does Workers’ Compensation Insurance Cost?

If you are looking for the best cyber insurance for your company, be sure to shop around with a few companies or with a digital broker like CoverWallet, Simply Business, or commercialinsurance.net to compare several quotes to select the best one for you.

Last Thoughts

Many states require workers compensation insurance if you have even one employee. If that’s what you want, Pie could work for you. If you need other types of business insurance, it will redirect you to either Progressive or Hiscox. In other words, to get a quote with Pie, you should mainly be interested in workers compensation insurance. You can add on other types of insurance, but if those types of insurance are what you really want, you could probably shop around more to get a better price. However, many small business owners do need workers compensation insurance and Pie makes that easy. 

Thang Truong

Thang Truong covers small business insurance and small business success at BravoPolicy. He is a licensed P&C insurance agent. Previously, he held product leadership positions at realtor.com, Capital One, NerdWallet, and Mulberry Technology. He holds a MBA degree from UC Berkeley - Haas School of Business.

More Stories

Nationwide Small Business Insurance Review 2022

Starting in 1926, Nationwide has become one of the largest insurance carriers in the country, offering a broad range of insurance products such as asset management services, banking, savings plans, and retirement solutions. It has over 500,000 small business customers and places #69 on the Fortune 100 list, which comprises of the top 100 companies […]

Next Insurance Review 2022

Next Insurance company was launched in 2015, with the goal of providing small business owners a more pleasant and efficient way of purchasing insurance. You can purchase all your business insurance online, without ever talking to an agent or a broker.  The way they do that is through AI technology, although you can talk to […]

Thimble Small Business Insurance Review 2022

A relative newcomer to the insurance field, Thimble launched in 2016 and is already making waves. It was initially developed to bring liability insurance to drone operators, but customers loved it so much they asked about other industries. Eventually, Thimble expanded to cover 100 small business professions. Rather than lock you into a policy for […]

Auto Owners Small Business Insurance Review 2022

Auto Owners Insurance has been around for a long time, since 1916. It is one of the nation’s largest insurers, providing insurance to nearly three million policyholders. Licensed agents sell home, auto, life and business insurance. Their agent network is quite extensive, with over 47,000 agents in more than 6,300 agencies across the United States.  […]

The Hartford Small Business Insurance Review 2022

Choosing the correct small business insurance can be one of the most important decisions you’ll make as a small business owner. Finding the right policies can mean the difference between not having enough coverage and keeping your assets protected in the case of a lawsuit. Below we’ll take a look at the Hartford in terms […]

Chubb Small Business Insurance Review 2022

If you’re a business owner shopping around for small business insurance, you’ll want to consider and get quotes from a variety of insurance companies. One such company is Chubb, which is the world’s largest publicly traded property and casualty insurance company in the world.   If you buy a policy through Chubb, you can either do […]

Travelers Small Business Insurance Review 2022

The Travelers is the one under the big red umbrella. The carrier began in 1864 as the St. Paul Fire and Marine Insurance Company. They are one of the largest insurance companies in the world, and the only property casualty company on the Dow Jones Industrial Average. They were purchased by MetLife in 2006, but […]

Liberty Mutual Small Business Insurance Review 2022

As a small business owner, it’s important to protect your business from unexpected problems. You’ll need to look into small business insurance so that your assets are protected. You’ll want to consider quotes from many different insurance companies so you can get the best one for you. Here, we take a look at Liberty Mutual […]

AIG Small Business Insurance Review 2022

Insuring your business is one of the most important things you’ll do as a small business owner. It can mean being protected from a lawsuit or disaster that might have otherwise put your operations in financial jeopardy. One larger insurer that offers business insurance is AIG. Below we’ll look at the products AIG offers, the […]

Cincinnati Small Business Insurance Review 2022

You have a large amount of choices when it comes to finding insurance for your small business. One factor in those choices is picking between a larger insurer and a smaller insurer. Smaller insurers tend to offer a more customized, personal experience. One such example is Cincinnati Insurance. Below we’ll look at the products offered, […]